Tuesday, May 25, 2010
Violence against women is a real problem in the world today and although in many ways it is the same it occurs in different ways. For example the piece called “War Crimes” shows how rape and violence against women is often used as a tool to elicit fear and control during times of war. The rapes and violence not only exhibits social control over women but disrupts other factors in society as well. I think one quote that shows just how destructive this is to society is that “the stigma of rape causes some men to abandon their wives. “ ( War Crimes 613) This shows me how disruptive the violence against women is for the whole society and why it makes for a horrendous yet effective tool for war. Violence as social control is apparent in the other two pieces as well I think particularly in the piece about intersectionality. I think this piece showed a very good point about how women of color or a different race may be further socially constrained. The women who would not be accepted into the shelter because she could not speak English very well I thought were a very scary situation. Because this women was a victim of domestic violence but could not speak English she had to factors that were controlling her and even keeping her from getting the help that she desperately needed.
One main difference that I saw in the three pieces was who was actually committing the violent acts against the women. In the book Two or Three Things I Know For Sure the abuser was a step father, in “War Crimes” the abusers were soldiers, and in “Mapping the Margins” the abusers were partners. I do not think it matters who the abuser is in terms of the act being a terrible thing and a crime that should but punished but I think it is important to look at the differences in all the cases so that we may be able to come up with a solution because they are all done for different reasons. One positive thing that I read that would help in reducing violence against women was the law that was changed so that immigrant women did not have to fear their husbands in hopes that they would not be deported. Changing the law to allow the women to apply for a hardship so that they could not worry about leaving their husband in fear of deportation I thought was a good step for the many women who are in this situation. Although this is a good start there needs to be more done because solutions are not always as simple as they seem although this seem like it would be easy to do “ Many immigrant women are wholly dependent on their husbands as a link to the world outside their homes.” ( IWS 202 ) Connecting to an outside resources to get help is very difficult for all women who are faced with these difficult situations and even more so for these immigrants who are in a new place where they know no one and may not even speak the native language.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think you brought up a good point about the perpetrators in each piece was different. It’s interesting to see that it could be a stranger or someone the person knew. In “War Crimes”, the women were abused by soldiers they didn’t know. These soldiers were able to come into families’ homes and basically throw their life into a downward spiral. They raped the women and burned their homes, leaving them with their life broken into pieces. They women may never see these soldiers again, but the scars and memories still remain. However, in Dorothy Allison’s life, she was raped and abused by her own stepfather. This means everyday when he got home from work, she had to see him and try to live a normal life with him there. It must have been hard having to deal with the painful memories being brought up day to day. The same goes for the women in “Mapping the Margins”. These women who are abused by their husbands have to constantly deal with the abuse and horror of it reoccurring. Also, the fact that they aren’t able to get help puts them in an even worse situation. Like you put in your post, the husbands of these women are their only link to the outside world. This means that they would have to go through their husbands in order to get help, which would obviously not work. I also agree that more needs to be done with laws in order to maintain the safety of women who could be in these positions. I think with the help of the government, women could have a greater chance of getting help for these kinds of situations.
ReplyDeleteHere is a website with some of the Federal Laws about Violence against Women:
http://www.ovw.usdoj.gov/regulations.htm